what's happening / speeches / Health Services
Hansard ID: HANSARD-1323879322-170680
Hansard session: Fifty-Eighth Parliament, First Session (58-1)
Health Services
Mr GURMESH SINGH (Coffs Harbour) (17:00:07):
I move:
That this House:
(1)Notes that wait times in New South Wales hospital emergency departments are now worse than before Labor was elected.
(2)Notes that New South Wales's hospitals ought to be safe and secure and not places where attempted murder can take place.
(3)Notes that the recent example of 3,000 unread and unactioned emails at Canterbury Hospital is a gross breach of public trust.
(4)Notes that regional patients are losing health services and waiting longer for care.
(5)Condemns the Minns Labor Government for failing to deliver a health system that New South Wales deserves.
I speak today on a public interest debate that is of critical importance to people right across New South Wales. On this side of the House, we believe the people of New South Wales should have confidence that when they attend the emergency department they will be safe, secure and seen in a reasonable amount of time. Before the last election, Premier Minns and Minister Park were out spruiking their promise to improve the health system in New South Wales. Looking around, it seems to be getting worse by the day. Hospitals have become parking lots for ambulances, patients are sleeping on the floor of emergency departments or walking out altogether without treatment. According to the latest Bureau of Health Information data, compared with last year 6,500 more patients walked out of our biggest public hospitals without completing treatment.
The Premier asked the public only a few months ago to avoid the emergency department. He did not need to worry; they already were. In the last week alone, we heard of an alleged attempted murder in a ward with some of our most vulnerable patients and an un-actioned folder of urgent surgery referrals. In regional New South Wales, maternity wards go unused while women give birth on the roadside and patients see laptops instead of doctors. I am sure we all heard about the incident in a spinal ward where multiple patients were doused in petrol and one was set alight. The perpetrator, a man out on bail awaiting sentencing, had required police intervention for a separate incident only a week prior.
Some of our most vulnerable patients were left without protection as security guards slept on the job. The public and those patients deserve to know why this man was permitted near such vulnerable patients. Over the weekend, we heard about an unmonitored inbox with more than 3,000 emails and 16 overdue patient referrals at Canterbury Hospital. Four of those cases were urgent, requiring surgery within 30 days, and 12 were semi‑urgent cases, requiring surgery within 90 days. Our frontline health services are under immense pressure and deserve reliable systems to help them ensure that patients receive proper treatment and care.
The failures are not isolated to major Sydney hospitals. Investment into regional New South Wales health infrastructure is drying up, and inadequate staffing has left health districts with no choice but to wrap up services. In the Myall Lakes, a lack of funding from the Government has led to a hospital redevelopment with fewer beds, no cardiac care and a community still waiting on an urgent care centre. In Scone, the only obstetrician is set to retire at the end of the year, putting at risk antenatal assessment, birthing and postnatal care in the future. There is an active petition on the issue, and I urge the Government to take it seriously and provide the community with the assurances they deserve.
In Gunnedah, a birthing suite remains dormant. It is yet to be used due to staffing shortfalls, leaving women to travel almost an hour to Tamworth to give birth. There are growing concerns about the future of maternity services in Queanbeyan, with a number of GP obstetricians stepping away. That great maternity service has served the community well for many years, and we want to ensure that it continues. The Minister said he is aware of these issues but, again, there is no real clarity and no solutions are offered by the Labor Government. In the Northern Tablelands, the Moree emergency department has been operating without a rostered doctor. The member for Northern Tablelands asked the Minister's office about this issue, only to be told that the emergency department had "full access to a doctor". What did they mean? They meant a virtual doctor or, more accurately, a trolley with a laptop on top. In Coffs Harbour, a 14-year-old boy with a broken arm and nerve damage was denied surgery on the day of the incident, denied surgery the following day, and had to be flown down to John Hunter. Thankfully, he did not suffer permanent damage.
Patients are waiting for hours in overflowing emergency departments and healthcare workers are burning out under relentless pressure. Frontline health staff do an incredible job under immense pressure day in and day out, but the Minns and Albanese Labor governments are failing them. Workers are routinely staying back unpaid, skipping breaks and working through exhaustion just to keep hospitals functioning. That is just not acceptable. Instead of delivering on promises to improve our health system, the Premier and the Minister point the finger at their Labor mates in Canberra. The Government needs to stop turning up at hospitals for photo opportunities in the middle of the night and start addressing what is happening behind the scenes before more patients pay the price.
Dr MICHAEL HOLLAND (Bega) (17:06:06):
Improving access to treatment in New South Wales hospitals is a key priority of the Minns Labor Government. Supporting the health and wellbeing of rural, regional and remote communities is also a top priority. There is always more we can do, but this Government will never stop delivering a high‑quality health system for all people across New South Wales. Our Government is providing record health investment and is delivering new and upgraded health for communities throughout the State. We are delivering $11.9 billion of capital investment into health infrastructure over the next four years, with $3.6 billion in capital expenditure in 2026-27 alone. Over $1.1 billion will be allocated in 2026-27 towards rural and regional health capital works projects. Over the next four years, nearly $3 billion will be invested in health capital works throughout rural and regional communities across New South Wales, including new projects in Grafton, John Hunter and Orange hospitals.
This significant investment will support the modernisation and expansion of hospital infrastructure in rural and regional New South Wales ensuring that patients continue to receive world-class care close to home. The investments that are being made in 2026-27 will continue and complete the record health infrastructure investment in 21 rural and regional health facilities. I will list them alphabetically: Albury, Bathurst, Cessnock, Cowra, Eurobodalla, Finley, Forbes, Glen Innes, Grafton, Griffith, Gunnedah, John Hunter, Lower Mid North Coast, Milton Ulladulla, Moree, Muswellbrook, New Shellharbour, Port Macquarie, Shoalhaven, Temora and Wollongong hospitals. Some $83.5 million has also been allocated in 2026-27 to continue the $200.1 million key health worker accommodation program. Some $24 million of that has been received in the southern New South Wales local health district. This funding will help sustain the State's record infrastructure rollout in rural and regional New South Wales, addressing the increasing demand for healthcare services in rural, regional and remote communities.
The commitment of this Government to deliver the health facilities that rural and regional communities need is demonstrated by the fact that over 50 per cent of the total number of hospital redevelopments in 2026-27 are occurring outside of Greater Sydney, with projects being progressed across all corners of New South Wales. In the most recent quarter at my local hospital, South East Regional Hospital, the Minns Labor Government has improved treatment‑on‑time performance from 67.3 per cent up to 76 per cent. Ramping performance has also improved, with 95.6 per cent of patients transferred from paramedics to emergency department staff on time, compared with 80 per cent under the former Coalition Government.
The Minns Labor Government is also committed to ensuring that families are able to safely bring new lives into the State as close to home as possible. Under the Minns Labor Government, zero public birthing services have closed in New South Wales. Furthermore, since we came to power, NSW Health has opened or expanded 10 midwifery group practice birthing services across New South Wales. Those services are located in Auburn, Glen Innes, Port Macquarie, Queanbeyan, Goulburn, Moruya, Cooma, Bega, Shoalhaven, Wagga Wagga and Wollongong. Home birthing services have also opened on the Central Coast and in Maitland. A further six new or expanded midwifery, antenatal and postnatal services are now operating in Kempsey, Port Macquarie, Goulburn, Buronga, Lismore and Grafton. All maternity services in New South Wales are networked, ensuring women and their babies receive the safest care at the most appropriate facility.
The record of the Minns Labor Government when it comes to regional maternity services is in stark contrast to that of the Liberal-Nationals Coalition when it was last in power. Between 2011 and 2022 there were 14 closures and/or suspensions of regional birthing services. Glen Innes closed in 2022, along with Muswellbrook. Wyong midwifery-led birthing closed in 2020. Gloucester Soldiers Memorial Hospital ceased birthing in 2019. Milton Ulladulla closed in 2016. Bourke multipurpose service ceased birthing in in 2015. Casino, Manilla, Wee Waa and Bellinger River hospitals all stopped birthing in 2013, while birthing ceased in Quirindi in 2012 and Narrandera in 2011. There is always more we can do. This Government will never stop delivering a high‑quality health system for all people across New South Wales.
Mr MARK COURE (Oatley) (17:11:07):
I support this motion because people in my community deserve a health system they can rely on. When someone is sick, when their child needs help or when an elderly parent is waiting for surgery, they should have confidence that they will receive care they desperately need. At the very least, they should know their referral will be read. Yet a report on the weekend revealed Canterbury Hospital had more than 3,000 emails sitting in an unmonitored inbox, including overdue referrals for patients needing surgery. According to that report, 16 patients had overdue referrals. Four were urgent cases requiring surgery within 30 days. Another 12 required surgery within 90 days. These are people who were waiting for a phone call, waiting for an appointment, and waiting to find out when they could have their operation. All the while, their referrals were sitting unread.
How on earth does that happen? Who was responsible for checking that inbox? Who was checking that referrals were being processed? How long did patients wait before anyone realised something was wrong? The health Minister needs to answer those questions. This matters directly to families in my electorate. Residents from our community are sometimes treated at Canterbury Hospital when St George Hospital is at capacity. People in Riverwood, Beverly Hills, Narwee and across the Oatley electorate need to know whether they or their family members have been affected. I join shadow Minister for Health, the Hon. Sarah Mitchell, in demanding answers and urgent checks of referral systems across our hospitals, not just at Canterbury Hospital.
The obvious question is whether this is happening elsewhere in New South Wales. The Government needs to establish that every affected patient has been contacted, clinically assessed and given the care they need. We also need a full, independent review of what happened at Canterbury Hospital, with findings made public and clear responsibility for fixing the failures to ensure this never happens again. An apology alone will not give patients that confidence. I acknowledge our hospital staff: our doctors, nurses, paramedics, allied health professionals and administrative staff. They do an extraordinary job, often under enormous pressure. They deserve reliable systems, proper support and enough staff to meet the demands placed on them each and every day. They should be able to raise a concern and know someone will act.
The problems go well beyond one hospital inbox. Bureau of Health Information data reported in September an increase in patients leaving hospital without completing treatment. At St George, incomplete visits were up 27.9 per cent compared with the same quarter last year. At Canterbury, they were up 27.7 per cent. Those figures should concern every member of this House. We need to understand why people are leaving, what care they are missing out on and what is being done to bring those numbers down. For a family sitting in an emergency department, the experience is personal. They are worried about someone they love. They want information. They want reassurance. They want help. They should not be left wondering whether they have been forgotten.
Hospital safety also deserves attention. Patents must feel safe receiving treatment. Staff must feel safe coming to work. That means proper security arrangements, clear procedures and support when staff report threats or violence. And families in regional New South Wales deserve dependable services closer to home. Having to travel for treatment brings extra costs, time away from work and pressure on the whole family. The Minister needs to explain how the Government will address those gaps. Today we are asking for practical action: check the referral systems, contact affected patents, publish the findings of an independent review, support our frontline staff, and explain how waiting times and hospital safety will improve. Those are the basics of government. People in my community pay their taxes and expect essential services to work. Instead, this week alone we have seen chaos in our transport system, a crisis in our health system and cuts to bus services. The Minns Labor Government must take responsibility and deliver those basics. I commend the motion to the House.
Mr GREG WARREN(Campbelltown) (17:16:07):
I move:
amendment to be inserted
<>
Colleagues, we heard words such as "chaos"—
Mr Mark Coure:
Crisis.
Mr GREG WARREN:
Those opposite would know what crisis is, because it is exactly what they did to the health system in New South Wales. If they were not privatising it, they were putting a wage cap on our nurses. Even during the COVID pandemic, they said, "We would be lost without you nurses. By the way, we are going to cut your wages and put a cap on them." They are the cancer that infiltrated the New South Wales health system, and the Minns Labor Government is the cure, led by the Premier and the Minister for Health. I am not saying this because he is a good mate of mine, but Minister Park is one of the most engaging people I have met in my life. Under the former Coalition Government, one in four triage category 2 [T2] emergency patients at Western Sydney Local Health District began their treatment on time. At Blacktown Hospital, one in 10 T2 emergency patients began treatment on time in the April to June quarter of 2022.
Transcription in progress…